Self-Registrations Following Proxy Registration Status
Very occasionally we find ourselves dealing with a situation by which an instructor registers with the association in their own right for a self-managed account whilst still under the regulation and authority of a lead instructor. There can also be situations in which a lead instructor registers a ‘proxy’ (additional) instructor under their account and upon expiry or at some point thereafter, the named ‘proxy’ then looks to re-join BMABA with an independent registration of their own. This creates a unique situation in which there can arise a conflict of interest that needs to be carefully addressed to maintain a professional, politics-free community. We call this situation ‘first past the post’ in-line with this policy which we apply to make good any such instance.
What is the identifiable issue?
We must ensure there arises no situation in which either;
A current registered lead instructor is materially impacted by a registered instructor under their charge opening up an independent BMABA club in close proximity to their own club without permission.
ORTwo instructors set up clubs in close proximity which are locked into any on-going conflict or disputes that may harm or damage the association’s ability to regulate conduct effectively.
Mitigations & Solutions
In either instance, the matter shall be deemed ‘no issue’ if;
> The instructor whom is opening an independent account can provide written confirmation from the lead instructor that he/she has no challenge or issue with such a membership being established.
At the point of this blessing being given, the lead instructor shall relinquish any future claim to dispute or issue from the registration and the proxy instructor may assume a fully ventured account of their own.
> The lead instructor does not renew membership with BMABA
At the point there shall be no conflict of interest as the initially registered lead instructor will have no bearing on any such association matters.
Possible Outcomes
In most cases we look to find a viable alternative for all involved. We will exercise our best judgement to determine what is fair and appropriate however we will always enforce;
The right of the ‘first past the post’ – the first registered BMABA instructor – to determine whether or not they wish to give their blessing to a subsequently registered instructor joining in their own right if they are registered within a 28.5 mile radius of the lead instructor’s registered address.
The right of the subsequently registered instructor whom is looking to re-apply to do so if they can demonstrate no conflict with the existing club. This can be done by ensuring either written consent by the lead, a setup outside of 28.5 miles of the lead instructor’s current venues and/or the set up of classes in a style other than that which the lead instructs, subject to fair use (i.e: we would be unlikely to permit two styles of Karate but we would be open to discussing the subsequent instructor teaching Jujitsu if the lead only teaches Karate, for example).
Undetected Double-Registrations
In some cases instructors will take it upon themselves to register through the main website, bmaba.org.uk/clubs, without declaring the conflict of interest to the office in advance. Whilst our systems have the ability to spot some double registrations it is possible for slight deviations in the new application to evade this check. In any instance in which an instructor registers for their own account whilst a lead instructor whom has already registered and paid for their membership remains registered to us, our ‘First Past The Policy’ policy shall apply. If the instructor whom has re-registered is picked up by Compliance during an audit we will work with them to find a suitable solution. Ultimately, if no solution can be found, we will need to terminate membership (and any insurances) mid-point.
In this instance, we will ensure the instructor in question is treated as fairly as possible if no foul play is detected. This may include refunds in full or partial amounts and/or cover being transferred to our group company, MartialArtsDoneRight, to maintain goodwill and prevent any immediate difficulties to on-going operations.
We don’t take kindly to underhanded tactics. By this, we mean instructors who are registered under a lead instructor’s account and the look to setup their own club off the back of the existing club, employing any underhanded tactics that aim to transfer students and/or support from the current lead instructor to the newly established club. This cuts against the grain of integrity and respect that martial arts should instil and in such an instance our responsibility to compensate clubs or ensure on-going operational abilities shall no longer apply.